We'll Always Have Summer (Reprint) (Reprint)

Belly has spent her whole life torn between two brothers, and after two years with Jeremiah, she’s almost convinced he’s her forever. Almost. When they decide to take the next step, Conrad finally admits the truth he’s been carrying all along—that letting her go was the biggest mistake of his life. With old feelings resurfacing and heartbreak inevitable, Belly must finally confront what her heart wants… and accept that choosing one Fisher boy means breaking the other’s.